15 New Historical Mysteries to Get Immersed In

By Carrie McBride, Communications
April 4, 2025

Historical mysteries are a mashup of two popular genres and give readers the opportunity to explore different places and times in history through the exciting lens of a whodunit. Whether you're already a fan or are looking to get started, here are 15 new titles (published in 2025 or late 2024) that are either standalones or the first in a planned series. From Renaissance Italy to Gilded Age New England and beyond, these books bring history to life—usually with a murder to solve. 

Looking for more good reads? Try 30 Historical Mystery Series to Get You Through Any Crisis.

  • The Queens of Crime

    by Marie Benedict

    In 1930 London, the Queens of Crime, a secret society of renowned women writers led by Dorothy L. Sayers investigates the murder of nurse May Daniels, found strangled in a park, and must navigate a web of intrigue and danger as they challenge societal norms.

  • book cover

    Allegro

    by Ariel Dorfman

    Mozart, haunted by the mysterious deaths of Bach and Handel, embarks on a perilous journey through 18th-century Europe, unraveling a sinister plot that potentially resulted in murder while navigating his own meteoric rise to musical fame. 

  • book cover

    Girl from Greenwich Street: A Novel of Hamilton, Burr, and America's First Murder Trial

    by Lauren Willig

    Bitter rivals Hamilton and Burr unite to defend a carpenter accused of murdering Elma Sands, a mysterious young woman found in a well, intertwining a high-profile trial with their own political ambitions and personal enmity.

  • book cover

    Those Opulent Days

    by Jacquie Pham

    In 1928 Saigon, former childhood friends Duy, Phong, Minh, and Edmond, now influential businessmen, gather at a Dalat mansion for an evening that ends in murder; shifting perspectives reveal a web of terror, loyalty, and secrets, highlighting the impact of colonialism and economic disparity.

  • book cover

    The Case of the Missing Maid

    by Rob Osler

    In 1898 Chicago, Harriet Morrow, a determined young woman hired as the first female detective at the prestigious Prescott Agency, must solve the odd disappearance of a maid from a lavish mansion, all while navigating skeptical colleagues and uncovering dangerous secrets hidden within the city’s Polish community.

  • book cover

    The Blackbirds of St. Giles

    by Lila Cain

    Having escaped a Jamaican sugar plantation and won his freedom and an inheritance, Daniel and his sister Pearl arrive in London in 1782. Callously tricked, they find themselves in the rookeries of St Giles—a warren of dark and menacing alleyways, filled with violence and poverty and run by the cruel Elias. But under his dangerous rule is a brotherhood of Black men, the Blackbirds of St Giles, whose intention is to set their people free. Can Daniel use his strength, wit and the fellowship of the other Blackbirds to overthrow Elias and truly find the freedom he fought for…? 

  • book cover

    Murder at Gull's Nest

    by Jess Kidd

    1954: When her former novice's dependable letters stop, Nora Breen asks to be released from her vows. Haunted by a line in Frieda's letter, Nora arrives at Gulls Nest, a charming hotel in Gore-on-Sea in Kent. A seaside town, a place of fresh air and relaxed constraints, is the perfect place for a new start. Nora hides her identity and pries into the lives of her fellow guests. But when a series of bizarre murders rattles the occupants of Gulls Nest it's time to ask if a dark past can ever really be left behind.

  • book cover

    Glitter in the Dark

    by Olesya Lyuzna

    The search for a kidnapped singer in Prohibition-era New York leads an intrepid reporter from Harlem speakeasies to the dazzling world of the theater, all while grappling with her warring passions.

  • book cover

    The Queen of Fives

    by Alex Hay

    A master con woman in 1898 London, Quinn le Blanc has just five days to impersonate a wealthy heiress and ensnare a duke into marriage, but as she infiltrates the high society of the Kendal family, she discovers that deception and hidden motives run on all sides.

  • book cover

    The Boxcar Librarian

    by Brianna Labuskes

    During the Great Depression, WPA editor Millie Lang is sent to Montana to investigate sabotage at her project and uncovers a mystery surrounding Alice Monroe, her Boxcar Library, and the disappearance of librarian Colette Durand years earlier. Inspired by true events.

  • book cover

    Perspective(s)

    by Laurent Binet; translated from the French by Sam Taylor

    As dawn breaks over the city of Florence on New Year’s Day 1557, Jacopo da Pontormo is discovered lying on the floor of a church, stabbed through the heart. Above him are the frescoes he labored over for more than a decade. When guards search his quarters, they find an obscene painting of Venus and Cupid—with the face of Venus replaced by that of Maria de’ Medici, the Duke of Florence’s oldest daughter. The city erupts in chaos. Who could have committed these crimes? The truth, when it comes to light, is as shocking as the bold new artworks that have made Florence the red-hot center of European art and intrigue.

  • book cover

    Last Twilight in Paris

    by Pam Jenoff

    In London, 1953, a secondhand shop necklace bears the name Lévitan, a Paris department store-turned-Nazi prison camp, leading Louise and former romantic partner Ian to investigate her friend Franny’s war death and the fate of Helaine, a woman imprisoned at Lévitan when the Germans invaded France.

  • book cover

    Misery Hates Company

    by Elizabeth Hobbs

    Miss Marigold Manners is invited to a mysterious relative’s estate on the fog-shrouded coast of New England and winds up entangled in a murder investigation. She must enlist the help of an eccentric, colorful cast of friends and found family to save herself—and everything she holds dear. 

  • book cover

    The Gatsby Gambit.

    by Claire Anderson-Wheeler

    Greta Gatsby, newly arrived at her brother Jay’s West Egg mansion, finds her idyllic summer shattered by scandal, betrayal, and murder, forcing her to navigate the secrets of a glittering yet dangerous world of wealth and deception.

  • book cover

    The Birdcage Library

    by Freya Berry

    Scottish adventurer Emily Blackwood, living in Australia in 1932, is commissioned to find a hidden treasure in a remote Scottish castle, but instead uncovers a mysterious diary that leads her on a perilous quest involving a long-lost book and her own darkest secret.

Summaries provided via NYPL’s catalog, which draws from multiple sources. Click through to each book’s title for more.