Reader’s Den

Reader's Den: Elizabeth is Missing, Part 4

Welcome back to final comments and questions on Emma Healy's debut novel, Elizabeth is Missing. 82-year-old Maud Horsham, at the mercy of memory loss, is desperately hunting for her friend, Elizabeth. During her lonely but determined search, she uncovers the truth about her sister Sukey's disappearance in 1946.  As she struggles to remember, she also struggles to be taken seriously by her daughter, caregiver, doctor, and the police.  

  • Is Maud heroic, or is her determination to find Elizabeth a consequence of her condition?
  • Does she display exceptional courage or recklessness in her search? 
  • Is Helen worthy of our admiration and respect? 
  • What role does Katy play in the novel?
  • Are there any comic moments in the book?
  • Is the resolution satisfying?
  • "I can see they won't listen, won't take me seriously. So I must do something. I must, because Elizabeth is missing." 
  • Is the ending happy or sad?
Before I Go To Sleep

Elizabeth is Missing is a brilliant read. It showcases an older woman with dementia who refuses to be cowed down. It sparkles with wit and humor even as it deals with very hard subjects. It helps us to understand the frustration that people who are unable to communicate for whatever reasons must feel. It teaches us to be humane even as it entertains us. Next month, at the 67th Street Library, we will read and discuss Before I Go To Sleep by S.J. Watson, another fascinating look at memory and its relationship to identity.

Comments

Patron-generated content represents the views and interpretations of the patron, not necessarily those of The New York Public Library. For more information see NYPL's Website Terms and Conditions.

I really liked this book. My

I really liked this book. My mom has alzheimers and I can relate to Helen.

Thanks so much for your

Thanks so much for your feedback! Helen is one of my favorite characters because she displays grace under pressure. A single mother and a successful landscape gardener, she clearly loves her mother and does her best to be patient.