Click to search the Andrew Heiskell Braille and Talking Book Library Skip Navigation

The House That Elmer Built









Last week, the Tottenville community lost a piece of its history. On September 9, the century old Manor House, a beautiful waterfront mansion located at 500 Butler Boulevard, was demolished. Although the Butler Manor Civic Association attempted to preserve the historic house, it was torn down by its new owner to make way for the building of luxury homes.

According to the Staten Island Advance, The Manor House was built in 1908 by Elmer Butler after his original mansion burned down in a fire that took the life of his daughter. Elmer Butler was a "scion of the South Shore family that made its fortune in the thriving maritime and boat-building industry along the waterfront. At one time, the 65-acre Butler estate stretched from Raritan Bay across to present-day Amboy Road." Mr. Butler traveled to Europe in search of building materials that were fire resistant and hired Lamb & Richards, the architects who designed Theodore Roosevelt's Sagamore Hill estate, to design his new home.

Sagamore Hill, Digital ID 1636203, New York Public LibraryRoosevelt's Sagamore HillFor the past 45 years, The Butler Manor House has been occupied by the Staten Island Montessori School and I had the pleasure of visiting the school many times to read to the students there. I was always impressed by the beautiful white building and peaceful, rural atmosphere; it was almost like taking a day trip away from the hustle and bustle of the city. I will miss the dedicated staff and wonderful students, who exuded enthusiasm for books and reading. My visits to the school were often the high point of my day. The school has relocated to another Staten Island location.

For more information on the history of this home, SI Treasure Blog is an excellent resource. According to a recent post, the Manor House Estate originally included "a mansion, cottages, a second house, carriage house, several barns, outhouses, racetrack and a gatehouse." The blogger also states that the home currently on the corner of Hylan Boulevard and Butler Avenue is part of Butler Manor and served as the cottage for the estate's gatekeeper. And if you look very closely when passing Butler Boulevard, you can still see the original brick pillars that marked the estate's entrance.

photo by Gayle Alstromphoto by Gayle Alstrom

Since the Gatehouse is part of the original estate and even older than the recent Manor House, there is still some hope that it may be landmarked and preserved for future generations. It would be a shame to lose this important piece of Tottenville history and the last remains of Elmer Butler's extraordinary home.


Patron-generated content represents the views and interpretations of the patron, not necessarily those of The New York Public Library. For more information see NYPL's Website Terms and Conditions.


Amy, thank you for using my photo in your story. It made me happy to have made a small contribution to it.

Butler manor

My dad owned the home on 42 flower ave. I grew up in I think it was the servants quarter's. I want so bad to learn more about my childhood home and don't know where to start. Please if you have any information please email me. Thank you D. Crea

Butler Manor

Hi Donna, I'm you old next door neighbor. Hope you are well.

42 flower ave.

Hi Leslie! I remember you! How are you? Trying to get info on the old house!

Doing ok. Living in Northern

Doing ok. Living in Northern California.

Butler Manor

Hi Lisa. I am on a similar hunt. Hope you are well. Leslie Barron

Post new comment