Click to search the Andrew Heiskell Braille and Talking Book Library Skip Navigation

NYC Neighborhoods

Gotham and Its Garbage


 79782. New York Public LibraryIn the next coming weeks I will be hosting a series of programs on the subject of NYC sanitation. Below is a post devoted to the first program Gotham and Its Garbage: A History of Public Waste, Public Health and the Department of Sanitation. A Slide Lecture with Robin Nagle Ph.D.

No matter where you live or what your economic status is, in New York City garbage is your neighbor. You may live in a penthouse apartment and never actually touch the garbage yourself, but chances are you pass it all the time on the street. If you do live on a high floor, in a full service building, on garbage days you will undoubtedly notice a mound of filled fat black garbage bags piled high and long on the sidewalk curb, outside your building. When you have lunch at your favorite café, you may notice that the outdoor seating is beautiful but just beyond the greenery is a mound of black garbage bags. Everyone everywhere in New York City has an intimate knowledge of the garbage that is piled on any given block or corner on any given day. Like any disgusting entity, we choose to ignore what is a necessity and obvious nuisance rather than adequately address it. Not that any one of us could actually do anything to help change the way we process our trash. Because of this, we have an uneasy arrangement of being silent and patient, as the trash is picked up and hauled away. At the same time, we seethe with anxiety until the streets are empty of the big black bags that line the sidewalk at least twice a week, in front of where we live. For homeowners, it is hoped that no animal will tear into the bags for the chicken carcass resting inside or that a bottle collector will not aggressively rip through the plastic to get to a redeemable bottle, clearly visible through the blue plastic bag.

 806179. New York Public LibraryWe live in probably the greatest garbage producing city in the world, with tons of trash being collected daily. Garbage collection has had an interesting history in New York City from swine roaming the streets as the first street sweepers, to white coated men who swept the street in the 19th century into the 20th century, to incinerators and transfer stations of present day and a host of recycling attempts. Early on in NYC’s sanitation history, garbage was transported to the piers of lower Manhattan, piled high into big barges and then brought out to sea and dumped. This practice went on for decades. The many changes of garbage collection in New York City has been initiated through political reform and public health campaigns, plus simply education, throwing trash out your window is not the way civilized human beings live. Garbage collection has also been closely associated with the underworld, where crime families controlled the dumping of commercial trash. New York City garbage collection is a complicated affair. From the beginning there were always problems and there still continues to be. Nonetheless trash must be collected and dumped and preferably “not in my backyard.”

Please join Robin Nagel as she presents Gotham and Its Garbage, on Monday June 8th, at 6:30 PM at the Mid-Manhattan Library.


Patron-generated content represents the views and interpretations of the patron, not necessarily those of The New York Public Library. For more information see NYPL's Website Terms and Conditions.

Garbage remains a paramount

Garbage remains a paramount public health issue, even in the dawn of the 21st century. We have technology to harness energy from the sun, the wind, the water, and even from bug-eating robots, but we don't have the willingness to care about the trash we throw away, or how much we generate. As a recent public health graduate, I hope to one day reverse this garbage trend in NY!

Hi Camel, Congratulations,

Hi Camel, Congratulations, the world needs more of you folks. There is never a day in New York City that I don't see garbage trucks drving by. Garbage in NYC is constant and complicated, from commerical trash to single family homes the mess seems to keep getting bigger. On a recent canoe trip down the Delaware River, I stopped in little, very little town called Lordville right on the edge of the Delaware. We pulled up the canoe, climbed the bank and crossed over a railroad track that travels along the river. Someone in that little town said the train now hauls NYC garbage someplace far away, far away from the city. The thought made me cringe. This is the most extreme measure of the "not in my backyard syndrome." Maybe its all we got now, but I think we should not ship our trash out. The thought of NYC sullying someplace else, because we can afford it and the community that is taking our trash is poor and needs the revenue bothers me. I hope better solutions can me made in the future and hopefully you will be one of the ones that makes it. Cynthia

Post new comment