- Home
- My NYPL
My Borrowing
My Shelves
My Community
- Explore
New & Notable
Collections
Made at NYPL
- Research
Electronic Resources
Tools and Services
Collections
- Using the Library
Get Oriented
Services
I am a...
- Locations
- Classes & Events
- Support the Library
- Help
Reader’s Den
The Reader's Den: Edith Wharton's New York Stories
Happy New Year and welcome to 2013 in The Reader's Den!
Edith Wharton (1862-1937) was born in Greenwich Village into the wealthy New York Society that she would be famous for depicting in The House of Mirth and The Age of Innocence. Although she spent much of her life living in Newport, RI, Lenox, MA, and Europe, especially France, where she spent years in her later life, she is best known for her treatment of the stiff, conformist, aristocratic world of New York that she knew so well.
In addition to numerous novels and novellas, Wharton wrote poetry, books on travel, architecture and decor, including The Decoration of Houses, and dozens of short stories. She wrote prolifically despite the disapproval of her family, mental and physical health issues, divorce, and active participation in French relief efforts during World War I. Her short stories are housed in many collections, including The New York Stories of Edith Wharton.
Over the next three weeks, we will be discussing three of these short stories, all of which deal with their New York characters' attitudes towards, and sometimes obsession with, the past. Please leave any responses, thoughts, or questions in the comments section on each post to start the discussion!
January 7th-13th: "The Other Two" (1904): When Mr. Waythorn marries a woman already twice divorced, he doesn't worry about what people might say. Once married, however, he begins to be bothered by the same carefree manner that had attracted him to her. He begins to worry that she is " 'as easy as an old shoe' — a shoe that too many feet had worn."
January 14th-20th: "Autres Temps" (1916): After years of self-imposed exile, Mrs. Lidcote is returning to New York after learning of her daughter, Leila's divorce and remarriage. Horrified, because of her own divorce that cut her from New York's social circles, Mrs. Lidcote is repeatedly told that times have changed, but have they really?
January 21st-31st: "Roman Fever" (1934): Mrs. Slade and Mrs. Ansley, of numbers 20 and 23 East 73rd Street, have been friends and rivals for years. When these two Upper East Side widows vacation together in Rome with their daughters, the mood goes from nostalgic to vindictive, and a shocking secret is revealed.
Thank you for participating in The Reader's Den!



Comments
The Other Two
Submitted by Anne Payne on January 3, 2013 at 1:20 PM.
I expected a period piece about partiarchical attitudes that would be very distant to a contemporary reader. It turns out that with a few modifications the basic situation and plot could be the basis of a modern short story...or sitcom episode. The emotions and tensions wouldn't be exactly the same, but close enough!
The Other Two
Submitted by Corinne Neary on January 3, 2013 at 1:51 PM.
Thanks for commenting Anne! I will agree with you that many of Wharton's characters struggle with emotions and issues that we still deal with today. To me, most of her short stories hold up for this very reason. Please come back and comment on next week's post -- where we will further our discussion of The Other Two!
Free downloads from eNYPL / Project Gutenberg
Submitted by Elizabeth Waters on January 4, 2013 at 5:14 PM.
What a wonderful choice to start 2013 in the Reader's Den! I like that fact that you'll be discussing a different story each week, and it's always great to have a reason to read some Edith Wharton.
While I would love to read the stories in the beautiful NYRB print edition, I see there are a couple of people in the holds queue, so I downloaded free eBook copies of two of the stories from Project Gutenberg.
"The Other Two" is included in The Descent of Man and Other Stories by Edith Wharton
"Autres Temps" is available on its own.
Unfortunately, "Roman Fever" is still in copyright so there is no free eBook version available. With luck though, I'll have the print copy by the end of the month.
I look forward to reading the rest of your Edith Wharton posts!
Thank you Elizabeth!
Submitted by Corinne Neary on January 4, 2013 at 5:38 PM.
I'm so glad you are reading the stories! And thank you for all the information on how to get the stories - I also read the first two online.
Roman Fever can also be found in Wharton's Collected Stories, and the library has a good number of copies of this collection. http://nypl.bibliocommons.com/item/show/17167352052_collected_stories
thanks again!
Corinne
Small world
Submitted by Claudia on January 13, 2013 at 10:05 AM.
I just wanted to make two comments that fall into the category of, "It's a small world." While reading this over a century old story, I could not help but notice that that strange phenomenon that is NYC (one of the world's largets cities) where you seem to always run into someone you know and usually that someone is the last person you might want to see, has always been such. The other is that the same day I read this story, I saw a post from an old writing professor of mine from college who quoted another ancient writer, "If the same ardor, the same urge drives both sexes to love's gentle fulfillment, which to the mindless commoner seems so grave an exces, why is the woman to be punished or blamed for doing with one or several men the very thing a man does with as many women as he will?...This unequal law does obvious unjustice to women, and, by God, I hope to show how criminal it is..." Ariosto (a man!) in his Orlando Furioso, completed in 1532 A.D. Coincidentally, this quote kept running through my head as I read the Other Two and also thought about how Wharton had allowed Waythorn to refer to his weaker character qualities as womanly...very interesting. In conclusion, it is a small world and clearly the passing of time does not effect that.
re: Small world
Submitted by Corinne Neary on January 15, 2013 at 9:48 AM.
Claudia, thanks for commenting! I guess the more things change, the more things stay the same? When I read The Other Two, I couldn't figure out how Alice could have satisfied Waythorn's expectations, and what he wants from her changes from one day to the next. He blames her for his own insecurities, and starts to hate her for the past he was perfectly aware of!
Post new comment