Click to search the Andrew Heiskell Braille and Talking Book Library Skip Navigation

Game of Thrones Reading List: The Grouchy Librarian's Guide to Down and Dirty Fantasy

Share

The hype is done, the premiere of HBO’s A Game of Thrones has come and gone, and now the fires of curiosity are stoked. What’s this all about? Why all the raves?  Why does it prompt sci-fi and fantasy luminaries like Anne McCaffrey to proclaim, “Such a splendid tale and such a fantasticorical!”

The biggest draws of George R.R. Martin’s A Song of Ice and Fire series are the frank brutality, morally grey characters, and cutthroat political maneuvering in the centuries-old Seven Kingdoms of Westeros.  They ain’t kidding about the cutthroat part either.  The violence and themes in these books would make gangster movies blush like pretty maidens.

If the show or the books have piqued your interest in gritty, realistic fantasy featuring flawed characters, here are a few titles to check out.  A word of warning.  This is not fantasy full of lily-livered elves, broodingly sexy vampires, or kings proclaiming grand devotions to the good of the people.  Well, the kings do proclaim, but in the next chapters, people are dying by the thousands as noble lords and princely men grind out their power struggles. Read on to find more gritty fiction and perhaps see where Martin drew inspiration from.

Stephen R. Donaldson's Chronicles of Thomas Covenant was published in the wake of The Lord of the Rings' massive popularity in the 1960s and 1970s.  Beginning with Lord Foul's Bane, the series draws on similar themes of good and evil and shares the use of a mighty ring as the protagonist's magical talisman.  It turns the genre on its head by introducing a brooding and supremely crankly anti-hero in Thomas Covenant, a leper who finds himself transported from our world into the Land, a place of wonders where even his leprosy is cured.  One horrific act early in the novel has dire repercussions for all who inhabit the Land as Covenant battles Lord Foul over the course of six novels.  Donaldson's cycle is built on the fascinating paradox of a man hailed as the Land's savior, yet his condition will not permit belief in that world.

What if you angered a sorcerer puissant enough to wipe the very memory of your nation from the world?  What if none could even hear the name of your country?  And what if, in plotting your revenge, you fell in love with that sorcerer?  Guy Gavriel Kay weaves fascinating insights on human psychology into this tale of conspirators seeking vengeance and the reclamation of their nation, the titular Tigana, from a powerful curse.  The plotters demonstrate deep devotion to their cause as well as Machiavellian ruthlessness to achieve their aims.  Set in a world that resembles Renaissance Italy's multiple city states, Tigana delves into the deepest meanings of national pride while exploring its driving emotions and their effects on the human psyche. 

Mercenaries tend to have a bad reputation in fantasty fiction.  They are usually depicted as dirty, rotten scum in comparison to shining paragons of knighthood.  Glen Cook's Chronicles of the Black Company are not going to do their rep any favors.  The men of the Black Company, last of the Free Companies of Khatovar, are some of the grimiest, morally questionable characters one is likely to encounter.  The mercenary unit willingly puts itself in the service of the Lady, the world's reigning evil despot, by slaughtering their current employer and taking orders from an evil wizard named Soulcatcher.  However, its members are also a band in search of their forgotten origins, following clues left in the company Chronicle, which is kept by Croaker, the unit's physician and sometime conscience.  Memorable characters, including a pair of hedge wizards engaged in hilarious contests of one-upmanship, make this novel a grimy, gritty, and entertaining read about human beings making the best of bad situations often of their own making.

An empire built on treachery and assassination; a city of fabulous wealth about to be besieged; sorcerers employing the magic of warrens; memorable characters like Sergeant Whiskeyjack; and a grand backstory of ancient, forgotten history that informs the Malazan Book of the Fallen, written by Steven Erikson, a former archaeologist.  Imagine if human lives were merely cards in a cosmic poker game played by a pantheon of ruthless, uncaring gods.  Gardens of the Moon begins with a decimation of the Empire's nobility, and spins into a saga that encompasses a far-flung world of risen and fallen gods, mortals ascending to godhood, brutal religious warfare, tricksters, generals, fallen civilizations, and regular people striving for survival amidst the political and theological machinations of the world's rulers.  It's a series that manages to be grand and human simultaneously.  The second novel of the series, Deadhouse Gates, will have you cheering the military exploits of Fist Coltaine's Malazan 7th Army as they fight a harrowing rearguard action against religious fanatics in the Chain of Dogs.  The writing puts you directly in the bloody trenches or the muddy city alleys as the plot pulls you into the lives of its inhabitants.

Sometimes a reader needs something different.  As if gritty, realistic fantasy fiction were not enough, Paul Kearney brings readers a gritty, realistic, maritime work to devour.  Kearney, an author with sailing experience, docks his tale of Richard Hawkwood firmly in the human experience.  Political and sexual intrigue are the order of life in the omnibus Hawkwood and the Kings, a collection of the first volumes in The Monarchies of God, sends Hawkwood on a journey to the undiscovered West as the Ramusian holy city of Aekir is falling to the Merduk hosts in the East.  Populated by deserters, sailors, and honorable enemies, Kearney's book is a work of military fantasy that marries human vice with noble streaks and brings to life a fantasy re-telling of the Crusades, Salem witch hunts, and the Reformation.  Painful military choices, seedy bedroom dealings, and religious politicking have far-reaching consequences in this series.

All too frequently it seems some great prophecy governs the destiny of the hero.  Hero is born under the right stars, grows up from humble origins to become the grand high poobah slayer/nemesis of the ruling dark lord/despot/evil god.  He lost this time.  Instead, a being who became known as the Lord Ruler reshaped the world into a drab, mist-shrouded world, enforcing his will through formidable Steel Inquisitors.  How formidable?  Becoming one requires driving metal spikes through the eyes, out the back of the skull ... and surviving.  Brandon Sanderson's world of Mistborn: The Final Empire is filled with the oppressed, the ruling nobles, and no one else. Magic is the province of the Lord Ruler, the Inquisitors, Allomancers, and Feruchemists.  Normal allomancers can utilize only one type of metal to power their magic.  Mistborn allomancers can use all the allomantic metals.  Rarest of all are skaa (peasant) Mistborn, and two of these plot to overthrow the Lord Ruler's regime and to answer the question: what happens when the prophecies fail?

And now we come to a personal favorite of mine: the story of Fafhrd and the Gray Mouser. Ill Met in Lankhmar collects the first tales of Fritz Leiber's most famous creations.  Fafhrd is a giant barbarian from the frozen wastes of the North and Mouser is a short, slim thief.  Both are expert swordsmen who are not choosy about their employers, and both spend their lives drinking and wenching (no dainty princesses for these guys) their way through the great city of Lankhmar.  Lankhmar, built between the Great Salt Marsh and the River Hlal, is dank, dirty, and teeming with a huge variety of humans and vermin.  In short, it's perfect for a pair scoundrels to make a lusty living in pursuit of adventure.  The thrill of adventure is what motivates them in all their dirty and noble deeds and they find themselves working for such strange wizards as Ningauble of the Seven Eyes or Sheelba of the Eyeless Face.  Above all, they are utterly loyal to each other, and maintain a mordant sense of humor coupled with a zest for life in all its filthy glory.  In the end, despite their statures, they are two regular guys who love a good time and relish telling the tales of their exploits.

As for the correct pronunciation of Fafhrd's name, well, you will just have to check out a copy and read the tale of how these two met.  There's also something about juggling with the seven eyes in there somewhere... or maybe that's a different tale.

Now that your interest has hopefully been piqued, I welcome any suggestions for adding to this list.  I welcome disagreement too, because nothing's better than a good, rousing debate about favorite tales of legend and adventure.

Comments

Patron-generated content represents the views and interpretations of the patron, not necessarily those of The New York Public Library. For more information see NYPL's Website Terms and Conditions.

Great Job!

I've got a few follow-up questions for you: 1. How close is the HBO Game of Thrones series to the original books? 2. Um ... there are a bunch of books in that series, right? So how long could that TV show last, hypothetically? 3. Could I recommend any of the titles you mentioned to my teen patrons, or are they all strictly grownup books?

Thank You!

1. So far it follows pretty closely. Being condensed for TV it will of course leave some background out, but it is faithful to the story. 2. There's four books so far, and the fifth is being released this summer. How long it ultimately goes depends on how long Martin takes to wrap it up. Hopefully he doesn't go the Robert Jordan route. 3. As for teen recommendations, it depends on how strong their stomachs are. Incest, attempted child homicide, and rape are just the tip of the iceberg. These are very adult-oriented novels. Maybe your very advanced teen readers would be ok with it.

Two more for you very much in

Two more for you very much in the same vein: Joe Abercrombie's "First Law" trilogy (starting with The Blade Itself) Scott Lynch's "The Gentleman Bastard" sequence (starting with The Lies of Locke Lamora)

Thank you for the

Thank you for the recommendations! I'll add these to my reading list. Have you tried Red Wolf Conspiracy by Robert V.S. Redick?

Other George Martin-esque books

I would second the rec of Joe Abercrombie's work, and also add Patrick Rothfuss' Kingkiller books

I have been nothing but

I have been nothing but disappointed in the Kingkiller series. Bubble gum rated G boring!

I love these reviews, I'm not

I love these reviews, I'm not really a fantasy fan--until now that is. It was never my cup of tea. However, after reading about the dubious and duplicitous exploits of the anti-heros in these novels, I may have no choice but to widen my reading horizons! Job well done, Josh!

More examples

Adding to JRQ's suggestion of Abercrombie and Lynch, I reccomend Richard Scott Bakker's "The Prince of Nothing" trilogy of very dark but philosophically interesting fantasy novels.

Excellent Suggestions

I remember reading the first book about Anasurimbor Kellhus and Cnaiur. I have yet to pick up the rest of the series. Thank you for reminding me!

7 books in the series. Maybe 8+ seasons of the show.

Martin is committed to there only being seven books in the series. Seven gods. Seven kingdoms. Seven knights of the Kingguard. Seven colors in the spectrum. Due to the length of the third and fifth books in the series, to say nothing of the sixth and seventh that haven't been written yet, Martin has suggested that some books could be divided up into more than one season of the show. That would also give Martin more time to finish the series, since he's had a notoriously difficult time completing the fifth one, due out in July. Add another author to the list as well: Michael Moorcock's Elric Saga.

By that token, you could add

By that token, you could add a lot more than the Elric saga. The Hawkmoon stories (http://www.worldcat.org/title/hawkmoon/oclc/36072175&referer=brief_results) and the Eternal Champion (http://www.worldcat.org/search?q=1565041917&qt=owc_search) also come to mind. Hmm. Perhaps another read-alike list is called for when the next season of the show is released?

I second Ludwig Van's

I second Ludwig Van's recommendation: R. Scott Bakker's double-trilogy (i.e. six-book) 'Second Apocalypse' series is one installment away from complete. The two trilogies are titled: 'The Prince of Nothing' and 'The Aspect Emperor.' They're phenomenal.

Other George Martinesque books

Second Abercrombie's books...also recommend Patrick Rothfuss' Kingkiller books

Agreed.

Definitely agree with this one. The picaresque narration of The Name of the Wind adds depth to Kvothe and leaves you wondering about the other characters.

Very interesting to hear of

Very interesting to hear of these new books (at least new to me!). Here are some more for the list: Mary Gentle's White Crow and Orthe series Greg Bear's The Infinity Concerto / The Serpent Mage Susan Cooper's The Dark is Rising series Julian May's The Many Coloured Land series James Blish's After Such Knowledge series Magician etc Raymond Feist The Sparrow Mary Doria Russell (maybe not quite fantasy)

Fantasy for those who hate fantasy

So I've heard that the Martin books are "fantasy for readers who hate fantasy," which applies to me. I love Martin's work but am getting tired of waiting 5 years for each new installment. I tried to read Erickson's work and decided it was the stupidest piece of crap story I'd ever heard. I read the first Rothfuss book and won't be reading the rest. I read the Lord of Rings and thought it was awful. So my question is this: if I like Martin but hated Erickson/Rothfuss/Tolkien, is there anything else out there for me or did I just get lucky with GRRM? All the suggestions on this list seem a little too heavy on the magic and sorcery stuff.

Of the above series that I

Of the above series that I have read, I'd recommend trying Glen Cook's Black Company and/or Scott Lynch's Lies of Locke Lamorra. I love both of these series and have successfully recommended them to friends that are not in to fantasy before. Black Company makes me think of a Vietnam War chronicle set in a fantasy world. There is some magic stuff but it is used more like GRRM uses it, to flavor the world for the most part. The story is told (at least in the first trilogy of the series) almost solely as Croaker sees it and he is very much a regular soldier with a bit of a philosophical bent. Magic is a little more prevalent than in A Song of Ice and Fire but it never felt (to me at least) like it took center stage or overwhelmed the story. Lies of Locke Lamorra makes me think of a spy/crime caper story set in a fantasy world. Again, very low magic and the main characters are not magicky at all. There is alchemy, which in this world is basically the love child of science & magic. It has a similar feel to A Song of Ice and Fire in that the past had more magic and was more fantastical but the present day is not so much. Also, the starting setting is a kick ass fantasy version of Venice.

Thank you very much, sir or

Thank you very much, sir or ma'am. I'll definitely check those out and see if they float my boat. Thanks again.

I'm pretty much in the same

I'm pretty much in the same boat as you - I can't stand most fantasy books. I tried Erikson's Malazan series after hearing nothing but praise for it, and found it to be poorly written and cringeworthy; and while Tolkien's Middle Earth stuff may have set a standard for fantasy worldbuilding and the like, the man struggled to write an engaging story. Joe Abercrombie's books are probably more up your street. Start with The Blade Itself, and if you like it get the other two books in the trilogy (Before They Are Hanged and Last Argument of Kings). They're very blackly humorous books that subvert the usual fantasy tropes while also telling a great story in their own right. He's also written two more books in the same setting, which take place after his trilogy - Best Served Cold and The Heroes. But the trilogy will be enough to be going on with for now.

While more historical fiction

While more historical fiction than fantasy, I would recommend the Asian saga by James Clavell starting with Shogun. The similarities to GRRM are unmistakeable. I have to believe that GRRM read shogun and drew inspiration from it. The violence, sex, power struggles, unexpected deaths of main characters, and even messenger birds and bannermen are all things shared by these series. Shogun is pretty much A Song of Ice and Fire with less white people and magic

Another for the non-fantastical

For those who are in love with ASOIAF but are not into the magical/fantastical recommendations above I'd recommend Pillars of the Earth. All of the violence, religion, political intrigue, and underhandedness without the magic or fantasy. Just my .02

Post new comment